Opinion | Before You Hand the People Debt, Give Them the Dignity of Work
There is a dangerous idea creeping into our public policy debates, dressed up in the language of “opportunity,” “empowerment,” and “homeownership.” It is the belief that you can empower a people by giving them access to debt, without first giving them access to stable, well-paid employment.
John Maynard Keynes, the father of modern economics, warned the world about this nearly a century ago. He argued that no society can empower its citizens unless it first guarantees full employment, because employment is the foundation of dignity, stability, and freedom.
Turks and Caicos Islands is now testing that warning.
And we are doing so at our peril.
The Mirage of Empowerment Through Debt
The Mortgage Corporation Bill is being sold as a pathway to empowerment. But empowerment is not created by a signature on a loan document. Empowerment comes from income, and income comes from employment, not debt.
Keynes taught that when governments expand credit without expanding employment, they are not empowering citizens; they are exposing them. They are shifting economic risk from the state onto the backs of households who have the least capacity to absorb it.
In a tourism-dependent, seasonal economy like ours, where wages are stagnant and job security is fragile, this is not empowerment. It is wishful thinking dressed as policy.
Employment Is the First Duty of Government
Keynes argued that markets do not naturally produce full employment. Government must intervene deliberately through public investment, skills development, and industrial strategy to ensure that people have stable, meaningful work.
What does that mean for TCI?
It means:
You cannot build a mortgage program on top of an economy where thousands of Belongers are underemployed.
You cannot ask families to take on 30-year obligations when their income is tied to the volatility of global tourism.
You cannot claim to empower people when you have not first secured their economic foundation.
Keynes would say: "You cannot build a stable society on unstable incomes." Yet that is exactly what we are attempting to do.
The Government Is Handing Out Keys Without Building Doors
Before you hand a man a mortgage, you must hand him a job. Before you hand a woman a loan, you must hand her a wage she can depend on. Before you hand a family a 30-year debt, you must hand them a 30-year economic plan.
We have done none of these things.
And that is what makes the Government's own economic narrative so revealing.
On one hand, Ministers speak confidently about growth, investment, infrastructure, and development. On the other, they provide remarkably little evidence showing how that spending translates into measurable long-term employment gains for Turks and Caicos Islanders.
The evidence is now visible in the Government's own numbers.
The Government has presented successive budgets built around development, infrastructure, and investment. The 2026/27 Budget allocates approximately $550 million in public spending, including $62 million in capital expenditure for infrastructure and development projects. Government officials have also highlighted more than $1.2 billion in development agreements, an investment pipeline exceeding $6 billion, and multiple billion-dollar projects under construction. [suntci.com], [suntci.com], [newslinetci.com], [rtc89fm.com]
Yet one critical question remains unanswered:
Exactly how many Turks and Caicos Islanders will obtain stable, long-term employment as a direct result of this spending?
Not opportunities. Not pathways. Not stakeholder engagement. Not inclusive growth.
Actual jobs. Actual wages. Actual careers. Actual numbers.
A government that can tell us how many dollars it intends to spend should also be able to tell us how many Belongers it expects to employ.
There is no national employment strategy. No skills pipeline. No industrial development plan. No productivity agenda. No public works programme.
But we have a mortgage bill.
This is policy upside down.
The pathway to debt is detailed. The pathway to higher wages is not. The pathway to borrowing is being legislated. The pathway to prosperity remains largely rhetorical.
The Missing Link Between Spending and Prosperity
Government leaders frequently state that development must benefit Turks and Caicos Islanders. Charles Washington Misick has argued that economic growth should be measured by whether Islanders advance alongside development and has frequently spoken of expanding participation, ownership, and opportunity. [suntci.com], [suntci.com]
These are admirable goals. But goals are not metrics. A serious employment strategy contains measurable targets.
How many Belongers will be employed? In which sectors? At what wage levels? For what duration?
What percentage of jobs generated by Government-approved developments must go to Turks and Caicos Islanders? What percentage of management positions? What percentage of skilled trades? What percentage of professional careers?
The public has not been given these answers.
The Government points to projected GDP growth, low unemployment, record tourism arrivals, major developments, airport expansions, port projects, and large-scale infrastructure investments. [suntci.com], [tcweeklynews.com], [rtc89fm.com]
But GDP growth does not automatically become household prosperity. Investment announcements do not automatically become higher wages. Construction projects do not automatically become long-term careers.
In fact, despite billions of dollars in announced developments, the Government has yet to present a public scorecard that directly links:
Dollars spent.
Projects approved.
Jobs created.
Islanders employed.
Wages increased.
Household incomes improved.
Without that chain of accountability, public spending becomes an article of faith rather than an instrument of measurable economic advancement.
Consider the contrast.
The Government can tell us the size of its budget. It can tell us the value of development agreements. It can tell us the projected growth rate of the economy and the anticipated revenues from tourism, customs duties, and accommodation taxes. Yet nowhere has it provided the public with a corresponding set of targets for
Belonger employment, Belonger wage growth, or Belonger participation in these developments. The numbers exist for spending. The numbers exist for investment.
The numbers do not exist for the very people these policies claim to empower. [suntci.com], [tcweeklynews.com], [suntci.com], [rtc89fm.com]
This is where the Mortgage Corporation becomes particularly troubling. A mortgage is not a development strategy. A mortgage is a financial obligation. It is a promise extending 15, 20, even 30 years into the future.
The Government is now working diligently to create a mechanism through which citizens can borrow over several decades, yet it has not demonstrated an equally rigorous plan showing how those same citizens will secure decades of rising income to support those obligations.
The contrast is striking. The pathway to debt is detailed. The pathway to higher wages is not. The pathway to borrowing is being legislated. The pathway to prosperity remains largely rhetorical.
Debt Without Income Growth Is a Trap
Keynes supported borrowing only when it increased employment, raised incomes, and expanded productive capacity. Debt, in his view, was a tool, not a substitute for economic development.
A government genuinely committed to empowerment would begin with measurable economic security.
Before creating thousands of new mortgages, it would establish:
National employment targets.
Local hiring targets for major developments.
Wage-growth targets.
Skills-training targets.
Career-progression benchmarks.
Annual public reporting on Belonger employment outcomes.
Instead, we are being asked to celebrate access to debt while receiving few guarantees about access to income.
That is not empowerment. That is risk transfer.
What we are doing in TCI is the opposite:
We are expanding household debt without expanding household income. We are encouraging long-term borrowing without long-term job security. We are promoting homeownership without promoting economic mobility.
This is not Keynesian economics. This is economic negligence.
A Real Path to Empowerment
If Keynes were advising the TCI Government today, he would not start with mortgages.
He would start with employment. He would say:
Build industries.
Build skills.
Build wages.
Build stability.
Build the productive capacity of your people.
Then, and only then, extend credit.
Empowerment is not created by loans. Empowerment is created by the ability to repay them without fear.
A Mortgage Program Without a Jobs Program Is a House Built on Sand
We cannot continue pretending that debt is development. We cannot continue mistaking access to credit for access to opportunity. We cannot continue celebrating billion-dollar investments while failing to quantify what those investments mean for the average Turks and Caicos Islander trying to build a life.
If Government can calculate projected revenues to the dollar, it can calculate projected employment outcomes. If Government can quantify infrastructure spending, it can quantify local hiring targets. If Government can create a pathway to 30 years of debt, it can create a pathway to 30 years of work.
That is the standard the people should demand. Because empowerment is not a mortgage. Empowerment is a pay cheque. Empowerment is a career. Empowerment is wage growth. Empowerment is the confidence that twenty years from now your income will be stronger than it is today.
Until Government can show, with hard numbers, how its spending policies will increase Belonger employment, Belonger wages, and Belonger incomes, the
Mortgage Corporation risks becoming what Keynes warned against: credit extended without the economic foundation necessary to sustain it.
That is not empowerment. It is exposure. And the people of these islands deserve better.






Comments